jedberg 3 days ago

I'm Jewish, so all my Christmas's growing up were kinda the same. Sleep in, have brunch, wander over to my neighbor's house around noon to see what kind of loot they got and help them play with their new toys. Sometimes we'd go out for Chinese food and a movie.

But my favorite was Christmas 1999. My girlfriend was out of town with her family and there was no reason to go home to mine, so I was alone (my roommates were with their families too). I decided to go to the movies in Emeryville.

I was going to see Galaxy Quest, Bicentennial Man, and Man on the Moon. The timing lined up perfectly to see all three. About 50 other people were there to do the same thing. When it was time to go in for the first movie, a staff member came out and told us that it would start about 30 minutes late. This would of course cause us to miss all the other movies.

About 30 people stepped forward at the same time and asked to speak to the manager. :). We explained to him that it would throw our whole schedule off. Since it was Christmas, he was kind enough to adjust the schedule so that we could all see all three movies.

That was a great day.

  • Sam6late 3 days ago

    I'm Muslim, so all my Christmas's school and college days were kinda the same, 1980s. I would have a real small tree xmass decorated at home and no one would blink about it, then wander over to my christian friends' neighborhood around noon to see what kind of cherry and wine they were serving. This is that neighborhood now https://www.facebook.com/photo?fbid=1031546789002116&set=pcb...

    • abustamam 3 days ago

      I'm Muslim too and I always find it interesting to see how various non-Christian theists observe Christmas. Obviously we don't "celebrate" but I personally don't see anything wrong with partaking in the secular parts of Christmas (and let's be real, in the west, it's pretty much all secular).

      My parents felt otherwise when I was growing up, so my siblings and I weren't allowed to do anything Christmas related, but now my wife and I would do seasonal things like watch a live performance of Nutcracker or Pentatonix or TSO. And can't forget about watching the holiday classic movies like Elf and Die Hard!

      • sgt 3 days ago

        I spoke to a muslim who basically just "gave in" and started doing Christmas at home because the kids wanted it. With the tree and Xmas presents etc even.

        • abustamam 2 days ago

          Yeah that's probably more common than you might expect. My mom is a teacher at an Islamic school and some of her 1st graders would often say stuff like "we have a Christmas tree at home but my mom told me not to tell anyone," which might give you an idea of how Muslims view Christmas.

          It's not something I personally want to do for my family, but I don't think any less of families that do that.

      • Aloha 3 days ago

        I will argue that in the US Christmas is in part a secular holiday - given its sorta pagan origins that makes total sense to me. It's a solstice feast basically.

        • lolinder 3 days ago

          The pagan origins thing is a myth, btw—all the various bits which people point to as evidence still date back to a Christian-era Europe and cannot be traced back further. Christianity has been around for a very very long time and has had a lot of time to evolve its own traditions. :)

          For example, Christmas trees date back no later than the middle ages:

          https://youtube.com/watch?v=m41KXS-LWsY

          • JumpCrisscross 2 days ago

            > pagan origins thing is a myth, btw

            Saturnalia? (I’m watching your video.)

            Given how diversely Christmas is celebrated, it seems wild to conclude that it hasn’t been significantly affected by predecessor celebrations.

            • lolinder 2 days ago
              • JumpCrisscross 2 days ago

                That’s the video I began watching.

                What is the argument for it not having influenced many modern Christmas practices, including but not limited to the celebration’s timing in the West?

                • lolinder 2 days ago

                  The fact that there's almost nothing that overlaps with Christmas besides the timing, and that the timing has other plausible explanations.

                  FWIW, I'm very open to the timing having been shifted to coincide with other festivals, but that's not what most people mean when they say Christmas has pagan origins. They're not saying that Christmas isn't actually the day Jesus was born (I'm totally on board with that idea), they're saying that X, Y, and Z aspects of the Christmas celebration were originally pagan and were adapted for Christianity. I have seen no compelling evidence in favor of that claim about any aspect of Christmas traditions, and I've seen plenty against.

                  • JumpCrisscross 2 days ago

                    > fact that there's almost nothing that overlaps with Christmas besides the timing

                    The drunken revelry?

                    • lolinder 2 days ago

                      Given these two explanations for the drunken revelry,

                      1. Christmas has its origins in Saturnalia, but the only remaining similarity is the approximate date and the drunkenness.

                      2. Humans will happily accept any excuse to get drunk during the longest nights of the year.

                      I lean towards option 2 as a much simpler and more likely explanation.

          • Aloha 2 days ago

            All of the bits that do make up secular christmas, do have pagan origins, which is more or less my point.

            My general take is that every major religion has some sort of solstice related celebration.

            • lolinder 2 days ago

              No, they don't. That's my point—all the bits that make up secular Christmas have Christian origins and have become secularized over time. For every tradition that is commonly cited as having pagan origins, we can trace it back until it becomes entirely unrecognizable and it's still all Christians all the way down.

              As near as I can tell the myth of the pagan origins of Christmas has its roots in fundamentalist Christians who wanted to abolish things that aren't contained in the Bible. "Pagan" made a good rhetorical whip at the time, but it's since been taken as a serious approach to history by popular culture.

          • sbuk 3 days ago

            Nonsense. You're conflating tradition (tree in this case) with festivals and ancient religious rites. See:

            - Yule

            - Dísablót

            - Koliada

            - Lohri

            - Saturnalia

            - Yaldā Night

            - Nardoqan

            • lolinder 2 days ago

              No, I'm not. All of these are, to the extent we know about them at all (which in some cases we don't know much), entirely unlike any Christmas traditions we have today which are claimed to be pagan in origin.

              • satvikpendem 2 days ago

                How do you know Christmas simply didn't align itself to those holidays themselves, because after all, a year end winter feast is nothing new in history? Or that the traditions we have today may have at once been part of such syncreticization but then died out until the modern day? In other words we don't necessarily have to see such traditions today per se for Christmas to have absorbed them over its time.

                • lolinder 2 days ago

                  We don't. But we also don't know that they were, and we don't have enough quality evidence in favor of that hypothesis to justify the confidence with which it is asserted.

                  In the absence of evidence about the timing being affected by other festivals and in the presence of much evidence that all the actual traditions are far more recent than pagan, I don't believe it's fair to claim Christmas has pagan origins. The absolute best we can do is say that its timing may have been influenced by other, pre-Christian celebrations.

                  • satvikpendem 2 days ago

                    I agree but I also would be interested to see any proof for the claims you're talking about with regards to Christmas not having any pagan roots, where are you finding this information or rather, where can I read more?

                    • lolinder 2 days ago

                      I linked one example—a video on Christmas trees from a religious studies scholar. They have similar content on the date of Christmas, and there are plenty of sources on each other tradition.

                      Here's another one on Saturnalia from the same scholar:

                      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5lsctaPJSvo

                      • satvikpendem 2 days ago

                        Great, appreciate it. Merry Christmas!

                        • lolinder 2 days ago

                          Merry Christmas!

                          • Aloha 2 days ago

                            Merry Christmas indeed!

                      • rat87 a day ago

                        One small exception Russian empire turned a figure from Pagan mythology into a St Claus like figure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ded_Moroz But my understanding is that him handing out gifts didn't come from Pagan traditions and was a result of largely copying Santa Claus traits.

                        Later during Soviet times secularish Christmas traditions including Ded Moroz were moved to New Year's.

              • mollerhoj 2 days ago

                In Scandinavia languages, xmas is still called Yule. Not sure if having the same name is enough to prove that its a continuation?

              • afpx a day ago

                Yeah, but you can 100% remove Christian theology and still have a fun time.

                • lolinder a day ago

                  Correct, but that's because most of the traditions have always been somewhat secular in nature (with religious significance strapped on after the tradition was already going) and have only become more so, not because they were borrowed/appropriated/adapted from a pre-Christian source.

          • EchoReflection 2 days ago

            ChatGPT and Grok say Christmas either does or might have pagan origins, but not that it definitely does not have pagan origins (yes, I know "proving negatives"is very difficult†).

            ChatGPT: https://chatgpt.com/share/676c8fd1-b6e0-8005-a86f-d43ac17634...

            Grok: https://x.com/i/grok/share/8fQKIFO1WGl3nDVZ6uFaJmPTW

            †Grok on proving negatives: https://x.com/i/grok/share/kcHkjqzJ5lx5kMyl4GL0nMuw3

            • lolinder 2 days ago

              LLMs do very poorly at judging the truth of long-term myths. When something has been asserted confidently on the internet over a long enough period of time it becomes baked into the weights, regardless of truth.

              I provided a source from a religious studies scholar on Christmas trees specifically (one of the most frequently-cited "pagan" traditions). If you can point me to something with similar provenance I'll read it, but I'm not going to waste time on LLM responses.

            • singleshot_ 2 days ago

              Ok, but what about asking someone who knows (anything)?

        • abustamam 2 days ago

          I think Christmas is whatever one makes of it. Whether or not one believes it's a Christian holiday or Pagan holiday — celebrate/observe (or don't) how you like. My wife's family is Catholic and they believe it's a sacred holiday so they celebrate it religiously. Its origins aren't important to that effect. Many religious traditions can probably be traced to secular origins.

          Personally for me, it's a good excuse to take time off work and hang out and feast with people who also have time off work. I personally think that (at least in the States) it's basically a Commercial Holiday, in that it just encourages over-consumption, consumerisation.

      • rat87 a day ago

        The Soviet Union cancelled Christmas then later took the secular parts of Christmas (New Year's tree,a Santa like figure Ded Moroz/Grandfather Frost was original some sort of pagan slavic mystical figure before somehow being molded into a very Santa Claus character) and moved it to New Year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novy_God

        Soviet style New Year's is still celebrated in a number of post Soviet countries including I believe to some extent in some of the Muslim ones. It's also celebrated by post Soviet Jews in Israel and to some extent the US. Although the recent full scale invasion on Ukraine might effect popularity due to it's Soviet association.

      • almokhtar 3 days ago

        [flagged]

        • footy 3 days ago

          This is a weird and kind of rude thing to say to someone.

          • bloomingeek 3 days ago

            Indeed, the site rules infer not to be too argumentative. It's also a simple rule of being compassionate.

        • ricardobeat 3 days ago

          Why do you bother coming to a Christmas related thread just to spew radical religious beliefs?

          Happy holidays I guess.

    • assimpleaspossi 3 days ago

      A Jewish friend of mine would get a small tree and call it his "Moses bush".

  • kleiba 3 days ago

    > But my favorite was Christmas 1999. My girlfriend was out of town

    Classic.

    • jedberg 3 days ago

      FWIW I ended up marrying her. Now we go out of town together. :)

      • kleiba 3 days ago

        ദ്ദി˙ᴗ˙)

  • 29athrowaway 3 days ago

    Jews have contributed significantly to what is recognizable today as Christmas time.

    Many catchy classic Christmas songs were written by Jewish songwriters.

    • judah 3 days ago

      Jews wrote all the classic Christmas hits including:

      - Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

      - Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire

      - The New Testament

      • e40 a day ago

        You need to hit an open mic night. You are hilarious.

    • ix101 3 days ago

      That second sentence was absolutely not what the first sentence led me to believe what was coming!

    • ilbeeper 3 days ago

      We also contributed the protagonist.

      • 29athrowaway 2 days ago

        We all know that the protagonist of Christmas in 2024 are Santa Claus and the gifts. It has been massively secularized.

    • midnightchair 3 days ago

      Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer was written by a great Jewish man, how cool is that! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_L._May

      Rudolph has an odd nose, and he gets chosen to lead all the other Reindeer! Kids love this song. You teach it to them when they are young and they'll never forget it!

      • tux 2 days ago

        I’m sure this is just a coincidence than but Rudolph sounds a like Adolf, or in today’s concept Russian Adolf. And word red doesn’t help, as red was favorite SSSR color. 0_o

    • petre 3 days ago

      Bob Dylan has Jewish heritage as well, although I don't recall him writing any Christmas songs.

      • asveikau 3 days ago

        Didn't he go through a phase in the 80s in which he was super into Christianity?

        • petre 3 days ago

          Yup, he embraced Christianity, that's why I wrote "heritage".

  • i_am_a_peasant 3 days ago

    I’m Jewish too. But I’ve always been around people who celebrate Christmas. I don’t bother lighting the Menorah for Hanukkah this year since I live alone. I got half a mind to go to the local temple and sit with strangers there but I don’t really feel like it. Treating myself to some McDonalds a la uber eats today. I never eat the stuff.

    • bowmessage 3 days ago

      Please don’t poison yourself with that chemical food!

      • mathgeek 3 days ago

        I hope that Christmas finds you in a wealth of joy and whatever you’re looking for that causes such comments. We are all fighting our own battles and this is my sincere hope that you win yours!

        • stormfather 3 days ago

          Sorry, what? Not wanting someone to poison themselves is an expression of love

          • asveikau 3 days ago

            One meal won't kill them.

            • i_am_a_peasant 2 days ago

              if it makes it any better I had a plant burger xD, i find it hilarious how everyone fixated on the mcdonalds part of the comment

              • asveikau 2 days ago

                I mean I share the sentiment against low quality food and its effect on health, as probably everybody who eats there is also probably aware of too, but again, this is not the time or the place...

      • samatman 3 days ago

        All food is chemical food. That's why we eat it, for the chemical energy.

      • BrandoElFollito 2 days ago

        I am sure that nutrition was the key part of his message. Well spotted!

  • memhole 3 days ago

    This is the top comment I hope for on every Christmas. Some of us draw snowmen instead of Santas. We all get a day to enjoy in our own way though. Sounds like a great time.

    • duckmysick 2 days ago

      My upbringing was pretty secular but we still did plenty of snow angels.

  • ianwalter 3 days ago

    Wow what a great set of movies too

    • jedberg 3 days ago

      1999 is considered by many enthusiasts as a peak movie year. It was a great cap to a great year.

      https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=feature&releas...

      • JKCalhoun 3 days ago

        I punched in 1972 and there were some fantastic movies that year (The Godfather, Deliverance, Cabaret, Solaris, Jeremiah Johnson, Aguirre - the Wrath of God, The Last House on the Left, Silent Running, The Heartbreak Kid, Fat City, etc.).

        Also tried 1973 — same (The Day of the Jackal, Soylent Green, Westworld, The Wicker Man, Papillon, American Graffiti, The Sting, Serpico, Mean Streets, High Plains Drifter, Don't Look Now, Badlands, The Long Goodbye, Jesus Christ Superstar, The Three Musketeers, Fantastic Planet, etc.).

        I think they simply made better movies decades ago.

        • feznyng 3 days ago

          You’re less likely to remember the not great stuff from bygone eras. Not to say there aren’t peaks and valleys through the years, though.

        • kizer 3 days ago

          Maybe if they stopped the endless reboots, remakes, sequels and derivatives. There’s still a good one every once in a while. Oh well, I know what movie I’m watching today… you’ll shoot your eye out, kid!

          • smegger001 2 days ago

            Hollywood has done reboots/remakes forever how many remakes of "a star is born" for example has had three remakes (1954, 1976, 2018) since its first version in 1937. There is nothing new.

          • JKCalhoun 3 days ago

            Welcome to Hollywood's two decades of superhero movies.... I'm sure historians will greedily watch many of the classics of this early part of the 21st Century.

            It's Christmas, I shouldn't be so negative.

            I think I'll indulge in Alastair Sims' version of "A Christmas Carol".

            • cjbgkagh 3 days ago

              It’s the J.J. Abrams misery box storytelling that ruined most TV shows / movies for me. Turning lazy writing from a vice into a virtue. Many shows now feel like they’re actively and intentionally wasting my time, ironically curing me of my desire to watch TV/Movies freeing up time for better uses.

              The other lazy writing is the lack of conflict resolution enabling a continuous source of needless conflict, making an entire show out of a situation that could have easily been resolved if there had been a single ‘adult’ in the room. This has the added problem of normalizing the extreme confrontational or evasive communication styles as opposed to productive engagements. I guess this is what happens when TV raises a generation and then that generation goes on to make their own TV shows, each cycle worse than the previous. As bad as ‘engagement’/‘rage bait’ YouTubers are now I shudder to imagine what the next generation would bring.

      • lazystar 3 days ago

        huh, american beauty was 99. i always remember the "plastic bag caught in the wind" scene - when i was in middle school, years before i saw the movie, i was sitting on the sidelines during football practice and saw a plastic bag caught in the wind. it was hypnotizing, enrapturing - i dont know how long i watched, but that floating bag caught against the side of the school building was one of the most beautiful things ive ever seen.

      • vladgur 3 days ago

        Of course it was peak - the Matrix came out

        • globular-toast 3 days ago

          Nobody even knows about Dark City which came out the same year. Because the freaking Matrix came out too. That's just how many good films there were that year. If Dark City came out today it would be lauded as most original thing in a decade.

          • whoisstan 3 days ago

            I refer to dark city all the time when creating AI agents, when Kiefer would inject them with particular memories when the city stood still. And Shell Beach pops into my mind when I take the train to the former grandios Coney Island.

            Existenz was another unique underappreciated movie of that year and whose theme never got picked by any other movie. When Jude Law realizes that the Chinese food he is eating can be put together to assemble the gun my mind was blown.

            • BLKNSLVR 3 days ago

              The Matrix, Dark City, The Thirteenth Floor, and Existenz.

              Saw all of them in 1999 / 2000, my career direction was decided in that brief period.

          • koudelka 3 days ago

            Don’t forget about The 13th Floor, also from 1999.

          • OliveMate 3 days ago

            Worth mentioning Office Space as well for 99. All three of those films comprise the Pre-Millennium paranoid, existential, system of control trilogy.

          • vladgur 3 days ago

            Youre right, Dark City was amazing.

            But the elevator lobby shootout from Matrix -- that scene ruled my home theater configuration for at least a decade

          • AlbertoGP 3 days ago

            And Dark City was delayed after it was finished, it should have come out before The Matrix. I copy here my previous HN comment from June 2023: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36415981

            -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

            I watched Dark City years after watching The Matrix (on opening in the cinema) and I enjoyed it very much, have watched it multiple times over the years.

            Here is Dark City’s director Alex Proyas: “Alex Proyas on: The Matrix copying Dark City” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ytxjsetVIRM

            And this is a juxtaposition of some scenes with background music: “The Matrix vs. Dark City.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=moW17YHl6B8

            This is Mr. Hand [Richard O’Brien] talking in ”Memories of Shell Beach”:

            > It was a very groovy movie, you see?

            > I remember saying to Rufus Sewell [who played the protagonist], I said, you know, it actually, truthfully, it really doesn’t matter, does it, whether it’s a box-office success because we’re going to get paid as actors anyway, sorry Alex [Proyas] but this is true, we’re gonna get paid as actors anyway and isn’t it nice to be part of something which is groovy?

            https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrK4U6PEu94&t=1029s

          • rkachowski 3 days ago

            iirc scenes from the matrix were actually filmed on some of the sets from dark city. The atmosphere and setting directly bleeds over.

          • soulofmischief 3 days ago

            Dark City released in February, 1998. Great movie, though.

          • sgt 3 days ago

            Didn't expect Dark City to be mentioned in the Christmas thread. Great movie, indeed. Dark, mysterious and thought provoking.

        • mckirk 3 days ago

          Fun fact: 1999 was also 'peak public phone booths'. Ever since then, they've declined in number and now are almost impossible to find. Every year it gets harder to follow that damn rabbit...

      • cjbgkagh 3 days ago

        Oh that explains it, I thought it was just when I came of age. I did become suspicious that perhaps it wasn’t just a personal bias when I noticed the same movies on lists made by very different age groups.

        • jedberg 3 days ago

          I graduated in 1995 in LA. Going to the movies was something most of us did every weekend. Just show up and get a ticket for the next thing you haven’t seen yet.

          Many consider 1994 the best single year for movies ever.

          I got really lucky that that was also my peak movie going year.

          • TheSpiceIsLife 3 days ago

            It was around this time, in a little city of about 15,000, in South Australia, when my mum received a gift and voucher from Blockbuster for being in the top ten for most movie rentals in one year.

            This was a time when movies were on VHS tapes, and there was a bit before the start of the movie that said something like “have you seen every movie ever made?”[1]

            And at the time it certainly felt like we had watch nearly everything that store and one other had over the previous five years.

            1. https://youtu.be/VfuzebAAesk?si=z3-HYkZwJK6mmtWP - I think there was at least a couple variations

          • alex1138 3 days ago

            1994: Shawshank, Forrest Gump... can't think of others right now

            • jedberg 3 days ago

              https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=feature&releas...

              Pulp Fiction

              Lion King

              The Mask

              Four Weddings and a Funeral

              Dumb and Dumber

              The Crow

              Speed

              True Lies

              Interview with the Vampire

              Natural Born Killers

              Ace Ventura

              Stargate

              Clerks

              The list goes on. Lot's of movies that turned out to be classics or cult classics, or the start of some great careers.

            • Lio 3 days ago

              Pulp Fiction and Shallow Grave were two from 1994 that spring to mind for me.

      • auselen 3 days ago

        I wasn’t aware of this, was still a teenager at that time. May be because of this I was never impressed with later years…

      • j45 3 days ago

        That is one pretty unbelievable list.

      • tux 3 days ago

        The Mummy (1999) was the first theater movie for me, it was an epic experience!

      • ianwalter 3 days ago

        I guess I never really thought about it, but yea a lot of bangers on that list

      • globular-toast 3 days ago

        It was peak music too. I really don't think things have got much better since 1999. If you watch/listen to something even from 1997 it seems dated. But 99? Could have been made yesterday.

  • AznHisoka 3 days ago

    OK, i am ignorant, but why do most Jewish people eat Chinese food on Christmas? Is there something I am missing?

    • tasty_freeze 3 days ago

      Chinese restaurants are often owned by first or second generation Chinese immigrants who (1) aren't Christian and (2) haven't been in the US long enough to adopt local customs. Since restaurants often are marginally profitable, they tend to stay open on Christmas because there is profit to be made, especially since most of the competition is closed that day.

      If you are Jewish, Christmas obviously isn't nearly as important to your (often nominally) Christian neighbors and there isn't much to do on Christmas day. If you decide you don't want to cook, Chinese restaurants are way over-represented in the choice of open restaurants. Once you do that for a couple years it becomes its own tradition.

      I grew up in a Catholic household but my family, after years of making Turkey and spending hours cooking, for the past few years has switched to Chinese food on Christmas. I don't miss the turkey and gravy.

      • throwup238 3 days ago

        Chinese restaurants will also often have whole roast duck which is an easy way to get the dinner centerpiece if you’re cooking the rest. My family doesn’t eat out but we always get a whole duck on Christmas and Thanksgiving (it’s a 20 year old tradition at this point).

    • nozzlegear 3 days ago

      My Christmas Eve tradition with my wife for the last 14 years has been to eat as much Chinese food as we possibly can at our favorite Chinese place. Then we drive around town looking at Christmas lights while listening to classic Christmas music. Neither of us are religious, but we were both raised Christian.

      I came into this thread thinking that I don't really have any great Christmas memories. My family was poor growing up, my parents shouldn't have been together for as long as they tried to make it work, and my father had a lot of issues with drugs and alcohol. But now that I think about it, these Christmas Eve memories with my wife are my favorite.

    • woodruffw 3 days ago

      Others have mentioned that it's because Chinese places are open, but another reason is that Chinese food is (or was) not obviously treif, meaning that there is (or was) a degree of plausible deniability around eating it.

      Source: family apocrypha.

      • emchammer 3 days ago

        I was not aware that the error bars between kashrut and marit ayin are that wide. I figured that it was because of the intersection of Jewish middle class culture and Chinese culture starting in the 1930s, and because Chinese restaurants generally do not serve dairy products.

        • woodruffw 3 days ago

          I think those are factors as well!

          This is all apocrypha, so take it with a grain of salt. But my understanding is that this would be a case where marit ayin would not be a significant concern, since the Chinese dishes in question were not visually identifiable as e.g. pork.

          Or another framing: if you were a semi-secular family (like mine) that tried to keep a semi-kosher home, it would be easier to eat a dish that contained finely minced pork or shellfish or similar. American Chinese food fits those parameters while also being available on Christmas, etc.

      • ilbeeper 3 days ago

        I was under the impression that Chinese food is all about pork. Something like that Modi's rant: https://m.facebook.com/reel/1021462526286349

        • woodruffw 3 days ago

          There's also a lot of vegetarian/non-pork-but-fleishig Chinese food. But the point was more that Chinese food that isn't kosher isn't obviously so, especially 60-70 years ago when it was less commonplace.

    • james_marks 3 days ago

      It’s not just Jewish people; it’s anyone who doesn’t want to cook, and Chinese restaurants are historically the only thing open.

    • pitaj 3 days ago

      I believe it's because Chinese restaurants historically are the only ones open since they don't celebrate Christmas.

    • fumplethumb 3 days ago

      Most other places are closed. Chinese restaurants are typically open on Christmas!

    • chuckwnelson 3 days ago

      My understanding is it's the only other places that are open on Christmas.

  • Simon_O_Rourke 3 days ago

    I'm largely of the "hell is other people" mindset around Christmas, from the overtly fascist elderly relatives to the incomprehensible demands of immediate family. I would love just one Christmas like that!

    • andrepd 3 days ago

      Indeed. If you have a nice family to be around at Christmas cherish it, it's not so common as it seems!

    • BLKNSLVR 3 days ago

      I think people tend to fascism as they age, the more they've done and seen and accumulated, the more conservative they get and the more their personal experience of the world must be maintained, protected.

      Talk to them about their youth, when they were wild and rebellious. Find out what trouble they caused. Remind them, and it just might crack the encrusted exterior a little bit.

      • wholinator2 3 days ago

        See, i believe this is generally trueish for the current moment, has it always been true though? For example, I've already passed the time in which my father _insisted_ I would become conservative and have very much not developed anything like the conservative values of modern America. Though, maybe it's just that conservatism has drastically changed since the 70s. For instance, i certainly have become less insistent on things like UBI and more realistic about single payer Healthcare, but i have not developed disdain for illegal immigrants, the desire to force birth, anti-gay marriage, anti-trans, etc. Were these perquisites to be conservative in the 70s? I'd say im fiscally slightly left, but socially i simply cannot understand the rights positions, it just sounds like hater shit to me

      • vixen99 3 days ago

        Are you conflating fascism with conservatism? Stalin was a socialist, a fascist and a conservative in the sense in which the 'c' word indicates 'maintenance of the status quo'. Certainly conservatives like to conserve & we hope that means saving that which is generally considered worth conserving though opinions differ when it comes to the details. Hitler was a national socialist and most definitely a fascist. Unregulated powerful elements in any society will always tend towards a degree of compulsion to maintain their status and we're not short of examples in the West. 'and the more their personal experience of the world must be maintained, protected.' is merely an assertion which you choose to believe. I'm sure examples can be found but also plenty of counter examples. You can't generalize.

  • romanobro56 3 days ago

    If you started 30 minutes late you wouldn’t miss all the other movies just the middle one

  • consf 3 days ago

    [flagged]

delibaltas 3 days ago

Christmas of 1981 in Athens, Greece. I was 15. Father had died 3 years ago from heart attack at 42. His last words to my mother: "Educate the kids".

She did her best, given that my grandfather was old fashioned and had stopped her from going to school after she became twelve, although she was among the smartest in her class.

That Christmas she had bought me the brand new then Sinclair ZX81 personal computer. We were visiting the grandparents in a small village near Athens.

I spend the night by the fireplace with a small portable TV and the machine, typing in games published in the UK PC magazines of that time and occasionally watching the Chrstmas shows. Debugging my typos was the way I learned how programming works.

Nothing really interesting here, but I am remembering that night again and again so when I saw the prompt I felt I should share. Merry Christmas everyone.

  • kapitar 3 days ago

    My dad got us an Atari 130 XE for Christmas back in the 80s.

    On Christmas day, it ran a program which asked for our names (my sister or I) and then printed out a personalised message and small game.

    Only years later did I really think about him setting up this program days or weeks before hand, learning to code it all in Atari Basic, for that big reveal on the day.

    He always had menial blue collar jobs because of his working class Irish Catholic background, and he died before I really got into computers/dev later on in life, so I never really got to ask him about it.

    Enjoy the day everyone and hopefully build up some nice family memories!

    • p0w3n3d 3 days ago

      I remember my whole family playing golf on Atari 65XE - everyone: me, brother, dad and mom.

      • p0w3n3d 2 days ago

        Game's name was Leader Board Tournament

  • monero-xmr 3 days ago

    1998 - my father had abandoned the family - I received a TI83 and the instruction manual. Spent literally a full week teaching myself TI83 Basic from that manual. It had everything necessary - variables, loops, functions. And I did it all hand-typing it in on the calculator keyboard!

    • consf 3 days ago

      [flagged]

      • wipash 3 days ago

        What's the point of these AI replies?

        • Alex-Programs 3 days ago

          I assume they're there to write innocuous replies then occasionally shill for a product or push a political cause. Reddit is full of them.

        • cricalix 3 days ago

          YouTube's creator AI assistance leaking across universes? (If you haven't seen it, LGR did a video about the AI reply-to-comments stuff that YT is pushing - https://youtu.be/26QHXElgrl8)

          • tnias23 2 days ago

            I’ve never really been anxious about dead internet theory until watching this video. I guess I just never had knowing exposure to it. Surreal dystopia.

  • throwaway2037 3 days ago

    What a great story, the perfect kind of HN post. Did Sinclair advertise in Greek... Or did your Grandma speak enough English to figure out what to buy?

    • delibaltas 3 days ago

      I had seen advertisments in greek from the Greek importers of the brand. I had asked my mother for it and she delivered.

      Since you asked for the greek market I can share one more memory. About a year later, 1982, I wanted to upgrade to Texas Instruments TI-99/4A so I tried to see a machine up close going to the local representative. I ended up at the "company's HQ" which was a small residence appartment in the fifth floor of a building.

      I found the door open so I entered a room full with boxes thrown around randomely. After waiting alone for an awkward period of 5-10 minutes, the owner of the company himself emerges from the bathroom with a wet face and kind of surprised to see me. He listened to what I wanted. "It's somewhere there, go and have a look" it's all what he said. He couldn't care less.

      13 years later I had my own small company and reselling PC and equimpent was part of the job. The man with the wet face was one of the biggest suppliers in Greece, since besides Texas Instruments he moved on to be the representative of Intel and Microsoft and reseller of many others and the company became on of the biggest in Greece.

      Maybe his mentality ("there it is, go and have a look") never changed much though, because a couple decades later the company went bankrupt.

  • nopakos 3 days ago

    Heartwarming story! Fellow Greek here. Also made my family take the Amstrad CPC and monitor to an 8 hours trip to the village.

  • duckmysick 2 days ago

    That is such an awesome story! Immediate favorite for me. Can relate to typing in the code published in the gaming magazines. Mine was with memory-editing the game values, albeit not on Christmas.

  • ddgflorida 3 days ago

    I can identify with having a GREAT Christmas associated with a new computer. In my case, the same year, 1981, and a Radio Shack Color Computer, 16K Ram.

  • kaonwarb 3 days ago

    A beautiful memory. I felt like I was sitting next to you, watching over your shoulder. Thank you for sharing.

  • consf 3 days ago

    [flagged]

egeozcan 3 days ago

Merry Christmas! Mutlu Noeller! Frohe Weihnachten!

I was born in Istanbul, a sprawling, chaotic city that's a fascinating blend of thousands of cultures. Christmas was always a thing there, even under an Islamist regime. As a non-believer, I never cared much for religious holidays, but I did enjoy the cozy decorations and sipping Glühwein (mulled wine). Beyond that, it didn't mean much to me.

Now I live in Germany. My first Christmas here, back in 2009, was quite different. I was alone in a rented room provided by my employer, watching TV shows I couldn't understand on a tiny screen, just trying to pass the time. My laptop wasn't working (the charging cable was broken), and I was bored out of my mind.

Around 6 PM, there was a knock on the door. It was my employer, heading to a hippie-style gathering in the forest to celebrate Christmas. He figured I might be alone and decided to come in person since I hadn't answered my phone.

Of course, I said yes, and it turned out to be one of the most heartwarming experiences of my life. The group was incredibly kind, and even though I was the only foreigner, they went out of their way to make me feel included (switching to English when talking to each other, for example). The setting was magical: small fires inside carved logs, nature-themed decorations, and delicious food I'd never tasted before. I was so happy.

That day, my love for Germany grew a hundredfold.

  • jll29 3 days ago

    Thanks for sharing! And kudos to a boss who is also a friend - there are so many people far away from their loved ones, and therefore lonely, on what should be the happiest day of the year for all - so everyone, please remember who you could invite to share the enjoyment as described here.

  • flawn 3 days ago

    I wonder which Islamist Regime you are referring to - the current one? :D

cperciva 3 days ago

When I was in Oxford, almost all the students went home for Christmas -- for the domestic students it was easy to travel, and most of the international students were wealthy enough that the cost didn't matter to them. I came from a middle class background and flying back to Canada would have been a significant cost (especially since my scholarship came with a living allowance which was only paid while I was in the UK) so I stayed in Oxford.

My third year in college, we had a new Warden (head of college) and while he, like all the other academic staff, generally vacated the college over Christmas, he felt obliged to offer Christmas hospitality.

So he sent out an email to the entire student population: "Any students in college over Christmas are welcome to come to the Warden's Lodge for afternoon tea at 3pm on Christmas Day." -- and as I was the only student in college over the vacation, I had a lovely afternoon talking to the Warden and his wife.

Graduate students generally don't have much interaction with college academic life -- undergrads usually meet with the Warden every term, but grad students are left to the academic departments to supervise -- so it was a rare and precious opportunity.

  • jimbokun 3 days ago

    Sounds like a very Harry at Hogwarts kind of Christmas!

  • pid-1 3 days ago

    Interesting, I had a similar experience as an exchange student in Britain.

  • delibaltas 3 days ago

    I have seen movies starting like this.

  • consf 3 days ago

    [dead]

    • cperciva 3 days ago

      It does, doesn't it? This might say something about English authors -- a lot of them went to Oxford or other places heavily inspired by Oxford.

      • satvikpendem 2 days ago

        Seems like that commenter's comments are all AI, albeit with an atypical prompt.

        • cperciva 2 days ago

          Huh, I wondered why it was flagged. Seems like a sensible comment regardless of the author, though.

neofrommatrix 3 days ago

Indian (Hindu) here who went to a Catholic convent back home. My favorite memory is of a reenactment of Jesus’ birth on stage by a bunch of 10th graders (my class) and instantly falling for the girl that played Mary. I’m now married to her and we have a toddler. Merry Christmas!

  • jll29 3 days ago

    How romantic! Merry Christmas indeed.

  • gweinberg 3 days ago

    Merry marry Mary Christmas!

  • SwiftyBug 3 days ago

    Ok, you gotta tell us that you named your baby Jesus, please.

    • neofrommatrix 3 days ago

      Would have been a Hindu Jesus, if we had named him that. Missed that chance!

andyjohnson0 3 days ago

I was born in the late 60s so none of my childhood Christmas memories involve digital technology. But a memory that stands out was the year that I got a telescope for Christmas.

I was maybe about ten. It was fairly average refractor on a wooden tripod but, growing up in an environment where things like that weren't the norm, I didn't understand that at the time.

On Christmas day my family, my aunts and uncles and cousins, would all cram themselves into my grandparent's small council house for Christmas dinner. Then the kids would play with their toys and try not to get stood on by the slighly tipsy adults. Too many people in too small a space, but I have happy memories.

When it got dark, that time, I took my new scope out into my grandparent's small front garden to look at the moon and try (unsuccessfully as I remember) to locate a planet. It was very cold, and people wandering past kept asking me what I was doing. I could hear everyone indoors talking and laughing. Eventually it started to snow very lightly, so I packed up and stood watching the snow for a while and then went back indoors.

That was amost fifty years ago, but I remember how my universe suddenly got hugely bigger that day. And the snowflakes coming down in the dark.

I passed the telescope on to five year old friend a few years ago. I don't know what she makes of it though: she can get images from the Hubble and James Webb on her tablet, if she wants.

Merry Christmas everyone.

t43562 3 days ago

Merry Christmas everyone! Thanks for this great website where it is possible to have intellectual discussions no matter what odd and lonely place one might be living in. :-)

I have had to recreate Christmas for my family on my own - my wife is Turkish and although she is not highly religious (especially about food!) it was not a "thing" for her for most of her life.

When I was living in Istanbul with her, Christmas was just another working day although I noticed a somewhat wistful attitude - people who sort of wished to join in but felt they were on the outside. The occasional Christmas tree. It was very odd for me. I couldn't surmount those odds and I also had never had to be the initiator. When my mum died years and years ago, everything died.

Back in the UK it's easier and I have a daughter so I HAVE to make it happen. I'm not that good at it but today my daughter, without telling me, filled my christmas stocking :-) So the bug has caught on. :-)

Now it's time to have breakfast and open presents from under the tree.

I wish a very joyful day to everyone. I risk controversy by saying that Christmas was not originally a religious festival and whatever religion you are, you're not excluded from enjoying it. It was a "middle-of-winter" party and I think it was to keep Northern Europeans spirits up at the darkest time of the year. That it has turned into "good will to all men" is great but it isn't owned by any church.

MarcusE1W 3 days ago

Merry Christmas everyone.

Every year it reminds me how I eventually became an IT professional.

My parents took us children to the village restaurant before Christmas. Must have been 1983. Then we were asked what we wish for Christmas and I had not really thought about that, yet. Some of my friends have been talking about a computer. I had no idea what exactly that meant or what to use it for but it sounded cool. Computer. Also I knew that the brand was Commodore.

So when asked what I want for Christmas I said "A Commodore computer".

The next day it dawned on me that it might be a good idea to find out what my Christmas wish actually was. In a toy catalog I found a Commodore C64 computer and decided that must be my Christmas whish. I started collecting the limited info that was publicly availabe about computer.

In a proper Christmas story I would get my C64 and live happily ever after. But my parents were not sure if such an expensive present should be bought.

My mother found a book about the basics of Computers though and I got that later for birthday. Now I really wanted one. I sometimes took a 30 min. Bus ride to the neighbour university town and there was a department store with a computer department and you were allowed to try them. So all you had to do is use the book to prepare some BASIC programme at home in paper. Take the bus, find a free computer in the store, key the programme in, hope that it works on that version of BASIC and you had a programme.

2 years later my parents seemed convinced that I really wanted a computer and got me a C128. Much better BASIC for structured programming. And from then I happily lived ever after. Or so.

  • yodsanklai 3 days ago

    Was going to share a very similar story, I got my first computers for Christmas. We got first a C64 which got me into "programming", but I think it was the Amiga which made me the happiest. It was such an upgrade compared to the C64.

    Whenever I feel stress, overworked, or frustrated with colleagues as an IT professional, I remember what got me into programming and all the fun I had with these computers.

    • MarcusE1W 3 days ago

      The Amiga was my second computer too. And I have spend all my money on the M2 Modula 2 compiler.

      Then I could do computer school homework in M2 on my Amiga and just had to translate it to Turbo Pascal in school to submit it :-)

samanthasu 3 days ago

I am Sam. And I wanna say 2024 is definitely a challenging year to me as I was laid off and a lot of changes in this year. My fav memory from Xmas would be the year of 2019, celebrating with my bff in winter wonderland, drinking, laughing, and we were really happy since we were still students with no worries at all. Wish time could go back

  • egeozcan 3 days ago

    Hi Sam! I usually just upvote comments on posts like these, but I wanted to tell you that things will get better. You'll have many more moments in the future that will warm your heart on the tougher days.

  • jamestdsmith 3 days ago

    This too shall pass. Life goes on and up. Many times I’ve felt that something bad happened to me. But a few years later I realise it was a blessing in disguise

    Merry Christmas Sam

  • MarcusE1W 3 days ago

    When you are down and in a hole, one small good thing is that it goes up in every direction. Merry Christmas Sam and a much better 2025.

  • throw-qqqqq 3 days ago

    Merry Christmas and best wishes from Denmark.

    Your favorite memory warms my heart.

    I hope 2025 brings you more luck than 2024 did.

  • joisig 3 days ago

    Hi Sam! It will get better. Merry Xmas from Iceland :)

  • mau013 3 days ago

    Hi Sam!! Weather your storm. It will pass. Trust that you will find your way out of this. Merry Xmas from Spain :D

  • pewpew_ 3 days ago

    Sam, things always work themselves out for the better. You will be fine, keep moving forward.

    Merry Christmas!

jakebasile 3 days ago

Merry Christmas!

I had rented Final Fantasy 7 from Blockbuster so many times that my brother decided to get it for me for Christmas. Even though I never really snooped for presents he decided to mess with my head and wrapped it in two large bath towels and put it in an even larger box. This giant package below the tree for me, and it sounded like cloth - I figured it must've been a jacket or something until I opened it.

Another time I was looking for something (not presents) in my parent's room, and happened to find a very poorly hidden Playstation 2 from my father. The waiting until Christmas part was fitting punishment for accidental snooping.

Some of the finest memories are just a jumble of similar situations though. Christmas Eve was the night my entire local family would gather at my maternal grandmother's house, and we'd all have a big meal and sit around chatting afterwards.

Then there's that one Christmas Eve when I asked my now-wife to marry me. I knew she'd say yes but there's always that little bit of fear about it. I wanted to ask when everyone I loved would be around.

Time sure flies. Both my father and my maternal grandmother have passed since the last time we all celebrated Christmas together.

  • brian-armstrong 3 days ago

    The accidental gift finding is so funny. My dad got me a bike for Christmas one year. Of course it's really hard to hide a bicycle, and he put it alongside the side of our house in a part of the yard nobody ever went in. For whatever reason, I happened to be playing in that part of the yard and found it. I asked him why there was a bike stored out in our yard because I was not a very clever kid. In hindsight it's very funny to imagine his perspective on it.

    • jakebasile 3 days ago

      I ended up telling him later in life and he just started laughing. He had no idea I'd found it!

  • matheusmoreira 3 days ago

    Spending Christmas Eve with family is the best. Really cherish those moments. The pace of everyday life is so fast, it's easy to forget what's really important.

    Merry Christmas.

    • throw-qqqqq 3 days ago

      Truer words were never spoken!

      I see my family too rarely because of the everyday hustle. I love the holidays for the slow pace, the long lunches and dinners. Talking about nothing and everything.

    • jakebasile 3 days ago

      Yes, they're the feeling of Christmas I remember most fondly.

  • joemazerino 3 days ago

    2001 was definitely the FF7 year. Played all 3 discs during the winter break.

  • kaycebasques 3 days ago

    > Some of the finest memories are just a jumble of similar situations though.

    This is how I feel about Xmas, thanks for putting it in words.

mukti 3 days ago

Some of my favorite memories are the times I got video game systems. Most notibly the Sega Genesis and z scale trains I got in '94/'95/'96 (not sure the exact year, I was very young) and GameBoy Color in '99. I got a Xbox in '01, Xbox 360 in '05; but they didn't quite have the same "magic" that they had when I was young. Also as a young kid, watching the Rankin Bass stop motion movies on the days leading up to Christmas. Then talking with my brother and sister while we tried (failed) to sleep on Christmas Eve, watching more and more obscure Christmas cartoons and whatever else would come on TV late on Christmas Eve night/Christmas morning.

The best non-Christmas morning memories were just random times I was at family Christmas parties or gatherings. Seeing aunts, uncles, and cousins dancing talking having fun. As a kid, we used to have the parties at family homes, which was always fun and super memorable. Later we moved to a hall as the family got bigger and cousins started to bring their children, in laws, and friends. I can't really point out any particular memory as good; just all the time spent with family, not necessarily caring about what else was going on in the world at the time.

  • MarkMarine 3 days ago

    My grandmother broke the Christmas gift rules with my parents and got my brother and I a NES, Tetris, duck hunt with the gun, and I believe the Olympics with the power mat. Christmas windfall I’ll never forget, seeing my parents faces drop as we opened all those games and just ignored every other present. Grandma had a nack for tweaking my mom any way she could, one of the meanest people I’ve ever met in my life but this year our interests aligned.

    My mom was enthralled by Tetris, better at the game than anyone in the house by a good 10 levels, and basically impossible to depose from the controller. I think it softened the blow with Grandma.

  • a_t48 3 days ago

    Gameboy Color in 99, too. Pokemon Gold all the way through the Y2K New Years was nice.

  • Dracophoenix 3 days ago

    > watching more and more obscure Christmas cartoons and whatever else would come on TV late on Christmas Eve night/Christmas morning.

    Which ones if you're able to recall?

WarOnPrivacy 2 days ago

My (14yrs older) brother stared a business on the back of our rural property and later build a home on acreage next door. The biz was a mixed bag for my mom and us. I had steady work from 9-19 (along w/ all of my friends) but all the peace and quiet went away.

That slowly became a schism between our already chaotic households (his wife, my mom) It culminated with him buying my 100yo birth home, suddenly evicting us and then razing the house to make sure we never returned. I was 19 and homeless. Also, my mom had terminal cancer.

Nevertheless, my best Christmas memory is just me and my brother and a walk in the woods. There isn't much to it other than an exceptional moment where having a brother felt like a good thing.

When I was 16, we (Wash DC region) had a rare white Christmas. My brother called the house early and invited me to walk. No families, just us, the snow and the woods (the land was my childhood and is all gone now). Mostly he called me because he had coke and wanted company. (His wife didn't know; he did quit after.)

For that hour or so, we were happy and unburdened by everything we'd ever done to each other. The morning felt like a gift. Probably our last one.

rawgabbit 3 days ago

May you all find Peace and comfort this Christmas. I had a somewhat traumatic childhood but Christmas Eve was the one day I could count on to find solace. Despite the dysfunction of family, attending Christmas Mass and in later years watching the televised Christmas Eve mass from the Vatican was always a calming experience. God is love. We are his children, brothers and sisters. We may not understand the mystery of life. But we have faith in God whose mercy endures forever.

  • nozzlegear 3 days ago

    Peace and comfort to you as well!

tasty_freeze 3 days ago

I grew up in a family with eight kids. Mom was stay at home and Dad did well, but with eight kids each individual kid received a few mostly modest presents.

When I was in college and home for Thanksgiving, my folks invited everyone out to dinner. After ordering, my dad would often introduce a topic of discussion that we'd bat around until the food came. That year he said: if you didn't need to worry about money or success, what other career path might you find interesting. Without much thought I said, I'd like to play electric bass, due to the fact that when I listened to albums, I was really mostly following the bass. I don't even recall what my other siblings said.

On Christmas day there were the usual gifts: socks and underwear, a couple of new shirts, and a book or two. But after that was all done, my dad said: tomorrow when the music store is open, let's go buy a bass. It was a $200 hondo (a fender p-bass knockoff) and a 15 watt Crate amp. What an extravagant gift! I'm 60 now and still playing, though never professionally. :-)

  • zoomablemind 3 days ago

    > ...That year he said: if you didn't need to worry about money or success, what other career path might you find interesting.

    Such a wise way to both elicit ideas and encourage introspection. Very inspiring!

  • bradleyy 3 days ago

    I also play electric bass, and love this story. The real question is: do you still have the Hondo?

    • tasty_freeze 2 days ago

      No, the hondo is long gone. After college, when I had a job, I bought a much better bass. I don't have any recollection what I did with the hondo. It would have been the mid to late 80s, so there was no craigslist to sell it.

      That hondo had action so high I needed to attach a parachute to each note I played.

dirtybirdnj 3 days ago

Growing up in NJ my family got together at my uncles place for Christmas, which also happens to be my cousin's birthday. I'm not sure if this was directly on the holiday but it WAS winter / snowy so we're gonna roll with it.

My dad had brought over a self-propelled walk behind snowblower to help my uncle clear a sidewalk in front of the house. My cousin and I were doing as kids did in the 90s, running around in the snow having fun when we made a discovery. A squirrel had not survived the cold and was frozen solid.

My dad and uncle had gone inside for some reason and left the snowblower unattended. We decided that it would be really funny if we put the squirrel in the snowblower chute, so that when they turned it on it would shoot out and we'd all have a good laugh.

Except that isn't what happened. The frozen squirrel blocked the auger mechanism from working correctly and after some very unpleasant noises some kind of belt or other part broke. The squirrel was not hilariously propelled across the sky as anticipated / desired.

My dad and uncle were PISSED, I am sure there was some fallout but it's gotta be one of my all time favorite holiday / winter shenanigans I've been involved with.

On a sad note, this is my first Christmas alone after going through divorce earlier this year. I hope you get to spend time with your loved ones, and I encourage you to remind them how you feel about them. You never know how much time you have left, so make the most of it. You have less than you think don't wait. Tell them now.

zulban 3 days ago

1992 my family just got a VCR but hardly had any tapes. For some reason my sister and brother were obsessed with Home Alone and as the youngest and a toddler, I played along with the excitement. My dad set up "some new movie" to play in our basement but said he couldn't get Home Alone, saying it cost too much, sorry. We eagerly watched the title intro which in retrospect, was obviously Home Alone. Once the oldest sibling finally read "Home Alone" we all completely lost our minds.

We even have this whole thing on video.

jadenPete 3 days ago

Merry Christmas!

Up until I was about 10 years old, my family would drive to my grandparents’ house every year to celebrate Christmas Eve with my extended family. We’d track Santa using the NORAD Santa tracker (which, by coincidence, reports Santa being in San Francisco as I type this) and open presents from my grandparents.

One year, I got a Kindle Fire, which was the first computing device I called my own. Because I didn’t have my own computer and the family computer was usually being used, I did most of my early programming on the Kindle by downloading an app called AIDE that allowed me to compile Android apps on Android (of which the Kindle ran a modified version) and sideload them. By the time next Christmas had rolled around, I’d built my first complete Android application—a graphing calculator complete with support for basic algebraic expressions, trigonometric functions, and a page that explained what every supported mathematical function did and how it worked. I was so excited to show my cousins and grandparents.

fumeux_fume 3 days ago

My fondest memories of Christmas are from childhood when we’d spend Christmas eve and day at my grandparents house in Pasadena with my aunts and uncles and their families. The kids usually shared a few rooms and in the morning our stockings would be hung on the doorknobs so we could entertain ourselves silly putty, highlights magazines, and slinkies while the adults slept in. However, the Christmas gift I’ll never forget was my first DVD player. It was a discounted Proscan model, but still cost a bundle back when VHS was the dominant format. While fiddling with the menu for The Matrix, I stumbled upon the commentary track which I had no understanding of. I finally pieced together that I was listening to the directors talk about the movie as they watched it, as if we were in the same room together. This kinda blew my mind and set me down a path at a young age of appreciation for movies as an art form and dialogue between artist and viewer rather than just passive entertainment.

haliax 3 days ago

Came home from Christmas Eve shopping/sight seeing in Manhattan with my dad and baby sister to find that our mom had gone and gotten us a puppy! I’d never had a dog before. It remains one of the best and happiest memories of my life :)

  • jakebasile 3 days ago

    What did you name the dog? This never happened to me, but if it did I couldn't resist giving it a Christmas themed name.

    • haliax 3 days ago

      Polar Bear! He was a Bichon Poodle mix and his tail hadn’t grown in yet so he looked exactly like one of the little polar bears from the Coca Cola commercials

laurieg 3 days ago

I remember being given a large K'nex construction set as a toy at Christmas. I can still feel the visceral excitement of opening it up and looking at all the pieces, imagine what kind of things I'd build. I think the ferris wheel was my favorite.

A few years ago I was a bit down abd feeling like I'd never experience that kind of excitement and joy again. I've come to realize that now I'm older it's my job to create that same joy in others.

I hope everyone is having a wonderful day and can find a way to create just a little moment of joy for someone else. Merry Christmas!

  • brian-armstrong 3 days ago

    K'nex! They exist! I had forgotten all about them. I also (now) fondly remember the K'nex Christmas.

illwrks 3 days ago

Merry Christmas to everyone who celebrates it, if you're playing Santa for little ones I hope it was a success ;)

To everyone else, I hope you have a nice festive break!

One of my fondest Christmas memories was when my brother and I got a PlayStation 1 for Christmas, the excitement and entertainment was amazing, we had graduated from Gameboys to 3D graphics. My brother is very competitive so it was the best to win against him in the car racing game (Tommi Mäkinen Rally). I can't remember what other game we got but I do remember he and I playing Command on Conquer years later and that background music is burned into my mind :D

Years later with my own kid I have a greater appreciation for the expense and planning our parents went through to find one for us.

deanmoriarty 3 days ago

The year I got the original Gameboy, came with Tetris and Gargoyle's Quest. Must have been 1991 or so, was probably the happiest Christmas of my life. Incredible how I still vividly remember that morning, more than 30 years later. I opened the gifts and then we spent the day at my cousins’ eating and playing, I was the youngest among my cousins and it was so cool hanging out with them, slightly older kids, we stayed there from morning til midnight. What I wouldn’t do to live that day again, perhaps paying more attention to the adult conversations happening at the dinner table which I completely ignored as a young kid back then.

My parents have been so good and kind to me, we were never poor but money was always tight with my dad being a small business owner with some ups and many downs, and yet they never failed to provide memorable gifts when I was a kid. I was very happy back then, but just as an adult I came to appreciate the sacrifices they must have made for me.

antirez 3 days ago

Writing dump1090 in my parent's house :D Waiting for the only plane crossing the center of the Sicily during xmas time haha. In general, hacking here in Campobello di Licata at day, then at night finding all my friends, drinking with them till 4AM, then looping again: code -> gym -> drinking, all this in the background of staying with family.

  • ablation 3 days ago

    You wrote dump1090? Wow. Thanks very much. You’ve brought me a lot of joy as a hobby. And merry Christmas.

    • antirez 3 days ago

      So happy to hear that! Thank you :)

      • blankx32 3 days ago

        agree, great tool, thanks

calrain 3 days ago

Back when I was very young, with my family, cousins, all over at my grandparents place, having lots of fun.

Here in Australia, Christmas is in our summer, so we used to have watermelon seed wars where everyone runs around the house eating watermelon as fast as possible to build up a mouthful of seeds to use as 'ammo' to machine gun spit at everyone else.

Was hilarious, and a very long time ago...

germandiago 3 days ago

Merry Christmas. Feliz Navidad. Bon Nadal.

Back at the end of eighties and beginning nineties I used to go to my uncle and aunt (my mom's immediately old sister) home and I would spend time with my cousins, from which three of them were orphans. Fortunately the family could take care of everyone.

I would spend time with one of my orphan cousins (we are just one year apart) and my older sister playing some games like hide and seek around the house, I was hardly 7-8 yo.

My uncle and aunt are not among us anymore but at least I keep nice memories.

This was in Spain. Currently I am in Asia.

lazystar 3 days ago

three days before xmas in 2022, my partner of 6 years threatened to kill me because i was scared to travel through an ice storm to her mom's house. while she was downstairs getting her pocket knife, i texted her best friend for help and got her to call her and she talked her down. the ice storm prevented any travel for 2 days; we still made it to her moms for xmas, but i was gone mentally for the next year and a half.

broke up with her in may this year; this is my first xmas all alone. all my friends and family moved out of state years ago, and i spent all my vacation days and sick days studying for a coding interview that i had last week for my dream job. i bombed it, partly because of anxiety, partly because ive been procedural programming for 8 years and suck at OOP principles, and partly because the PTSD makes it tough to study/concentrate around xmas.

anyway, im drinking a bottle of mccallan, out here alone with my two cats, and its still a better xmas than the last two years. apologies for trauma dumping, just tipsy i guess.

oh and i did get the oracle java 8 associate cert last night, so i got that going for me, which is nice.

edit:

best xmas memory was playing KOTOR 1 when it came out, while eating a big tub of dansk sugar cookies. that dantooine music was lovely

  • whatamidoingyo 3 days ago

    > i bombed it, partly because of anxiety

    I feel this. Can't tell you how many interviews I bombed because of anxiety. The worst one I had spent like 3 months interviewing with the company, passed all of their tests, etc. When it came time to meet the team, I just froze. I answered all of their questions correctly, but it was like I wasn't myself. I became extremely slow, stammering my words, and just blanking out. The CTO couldn't take it anymore and said "just stop talking. This isn't going to work". I quickly ended the call without saying anything and felt so defeated. What is wrong with me.

    That was years ago. I'm much better now, mostly because I have the confidence in my skills, but it still comes up, especially when people are being aggressive during interviews.

    Anyway, Merry Christmas. I wish you the best.

  • olalonde 3 days ago

    That's horrible, sorry you had to go through that. I can’t even imagine the mental toll, Java 8 really?

    • drunkonvinyl 3 days ago

      That resulted in a loud chuckle. My mind was perfectly prepared to not expect a punch line, and it smacked me over the head. Thanks for the Christmas gift of laughter.

      • olalonde 3 days ago

        Glad I gave you a laugh, Merry Christmas! :)

    • lazystar 3 days ago

      my specialty's always been refactoring legacy codebases; java 8 is gonna be the new FORTRAN lol

  • jemmyw 3 days ago

    I don't know if there's a way to ask with sensitivity, but I'm very interested to know why you stayed with her for 18 months after she threatened to kill you?

    Sorry about the job, happens to the best of us. I think when it's the dream job you're that much more likely to bomb. I quit my dream job because it couldn't pay the bills and joined a place I thought I wouldn't last at, now in year 8 it turns out it was the dream job.

    • lazystar 3 days ago

      no worries, been asking myself that question too. my best guess is that i had disassociated because i couldnt bear the cognitive dissonance from accepting the fact that i was in an abusive relationship. before that incident, everything in that relationship had been going well - but looking back i see that i was slowly becoming more and more reliant on her for her network of friends and her family, which made breaking up a difficult thought to consider. anyway, the other thing going on was sleep deprivation from a severely deviated septum - i broke up with her in may 2024 after a couples counseling session, in which she a) tried to blame me for the stabbing incident, and b) admitted to kicking me awake every night over the previous 4 years when i snored.

      anyway. got surgery to fix that apnea issue in july, and ive been getting back to my old self.

      edit: the other jarring thing was just how successful i was at work. anyone that uses AWS lambda benefited from my projects in 2023/2024 - some of that stuff got L10 visibility inside AWS. i guess i spent all my mental energy at work, even though i was (and still am) fully remote/WFH. anyway it was tough to reconcile my failures in my personal life with my successes in work life - i was both a failure and a success.

      • roughly 3 days ago

        I had a relationship turn that way, too, and had the same reaction - it took way too long to recognize what had happened and to step back and realize what I had to do. I didn’t want to admit it was over, I didn’t want to admit I’d been wrong, and I didn’t want to let go of the future I’d been imagining. When I got out, I looked back and realized I’d basically played the exact script from every story you ever hear about that kind of relationship - you know, the story where you hear it and say “that was stupid, I’d have just…”, except it turns out I wouldn’t have just, because I didn’t.

        All that’s a long way to say I’m sorry for what you went through, and if any of what I’ve said resonates, you’re not alone and I encourage you to forgive yourself.

        Enjoy your Christmas. Being alone ain’t the worst thing in the world.

      • willismichael 3 days ago

        Godspeed, stranger. Sometimes just taking the first steps can be the hardest part of taking care of yourself. Keep it up, and best of luck during the new year.

      • lizzas 3 days ago

        Well thank you. My current job is probably only possible due to lambda!

        • lazystar 3 days ago

          nice. yw; lots of cool stuff coming in 2025/26. we're re-focused on the needs of the customer, rather than internal metrics.

          • lizzas 3 days ago

            Yep the isolation lets us run completely untrusted workloads. "Us" is not my team, I am adjacent, so I am not fully across which buzzwords but it is pretty cool.

    • jtxt 3 days ago

      OP's relationship story sounds so familiar to me.

      [Insert TMI story.] Cycle of abuse: https://psychcentral.com/health/cycle-of-abuse

      Fortunately, it ended ok. I healed for over a year before dating again, and dated someone for exactly a year to make sure it was good relationship. It still is. :D

  • jongjong 3 days ago

    It's hard to comprehend how much mental trauma someone must have gone through to be so unstable and violent.

    The range of human experiences is significant. Humans communicate using the same languages and same expressions but mentally, different people are wired very differently.

    Trauma seems to spread like a virus.

  • artimaeis 3 days ago

    Man that Christmas playing KOTOR was phenomenal. First game I remember beating and immediately restarting to see the other storylines. Christmas cookies for sure enhances the experience.

    • matheusmoreira 3 days ago

      I have a similar experience with Mass Effect. Completed the trilogy just in time for Christmas. Just getting lost in another universe like that is amazing and it's becoming increasingly difficult as I get older. Really treasure these moments, they remind me of a carefree childhood. Never played KOTOR myself but I always read great things about it. Look forward to playing it one day.

      Merry Christmas.

      • burgerzzz 3 days ago

        Same with 007 on n64

        • jamiek88 3 days ago

          Was just going to chime in with this. Goldeneye on n64 Xmas day, selection box and sticky controller. What I wouldn’t do to feel that innocent safety again.

  • edm0nd 3 days ago

    Cheers homie! I'll go pour myself some Angels Envy and drink with ya.

  • mynameyeff 3 days ago

    If you enjoy high-end scotch, you're a good person in my book.

  • mynameisvlad 3 days ago

    If it was the Seattle ice storm you're talking about, WTF. I could barely walk 10 feet out to let my dog out for potty/poop, let alone driving a car through that. The entire city shut down for the day.

    • lazystar 3 days ago

      yep. she had a dually truck and got home from the barn at 5pm; the storm was set to hit at 5:30. she wanted to load up the gifts, luggage, cats in the truck, travel 2 hours to a ferry down the backroads, and gamble on beating the storm. when i said i was scared, she went ballistic. never seen anyone get that mad before; being stuck with her in that house for 2 days after that was the worst moment of my life (as homer simpson would say, worst moment of your life... so far!)

  • CoastalCoder 3 days ago

    Sorry about the crappy part, and congrats on the good stuff!

    If it's any encouragement, I bombed a bunch of interviews during my 14 months of unemployment, but in January I'm returning to a position I loved.

    Just saying that you shouldn't extrapolate too much from even a string of such things.

    Hope your new year is awesome.

    • lazystar 3 days ago

      thank you, and congrats! best of luck in your new job!

vallard 3 days ago

I was a missionary in Montevideo Uruguay never having been away from home for Christmas. There were fireworks all night long and we were just outside with all the kids going to different peoples houses and just having a blast. Was one night I felt like everyone was nice to us and just accepted us.

Unbeliever69 3 days ago

The one thing that really stands out about Christmas growing up was how amazing my dad was at giving gifts that sparked my curiosity about the world. Instead of focusing on toys and games, he often chose books (scientific) and kits (RadioShack). While today you can easily find gifts that combine fun and learning, growing up in the '70s and '80s, it was usually one or the other. That’s not to say I didn’t enjoy a good toy or game—they could also stimulate imagination and creativity—but it was the books and kits that truly shaped who I would become.

I also had an aunt who loved giving magazine subscriptions. Thanks to her, I had long-running subscriptions to Discover, Scientific American, Omni, and later BYTE. And, of course, the most important one of all: Dungeon!

taatparya 3 days ago

At our company, we celebrated Christmas today exchanging gifts despite not having a single Christian person in our staff.

One of the junior introverted female developer was coaxed into being the Santa for gift distribution. She really shines as Santa and thoroughly enjoyed it. What's more, she even coaxed others to dance while accepting the gift and everybody has a good time.

My most memorable so far.

dusted 2 days ago

Christmas of 1996, a ten year old boy was spending christmas day in front of his TV, connected to it was his Commodore 64. The boy was angry and sad, and ashamed of being angry and sad, because his parents couldn't afford to buy him a PC, he knew it was an unreasonable wish, and he knew he could not get it. He was ashamed of his sadness and anger over not being able to get a PC (it was all he'd ever wanted since he was 6 years old), and so he didn't want to participate in the christmas dinner, he just wanted to be left alone in his dark and sad room and play Kickstart 2. He knew he was a little brat for feeling so, but alas he couldn't help himself, he felt like the future was rushing past without him.

After much convincing from his patient grandmother, the boy finally participated, his parents knew he had a hard time, and they told him that there was a present for him before the dinner (in our tradition, we open presents on christmas eve, after the dinner), so he thought they were taking pity on him, he said no, he didn't want any presents.

They asked him softly to consider it again, and he heard something in their voices and a feeling of intense shame came over him, he saw the giant boxes, inside it, a brand new PC, gifted from a wealthy, but distant relative who "thought it might be healthy for the boys development of his interest". He cried, out of shame, and out of happiness, and he grew up so much in those moments, to feel so undeserving and yet grateful. That computer was with him the next 6 years, a 100 mhz pentium, 16 mib of RAM, 814 mib (fat32 formatted) harddisk, 4x CD rom drive. 14" color monitor, windows 95, 3 button logitech ps/2 mouse, and ESS AudioDrive sound card(soundblaster 100% compatible). On that machine, he learned so much, and when he trashed it, there was nobody to help him format it, so in time, he figured it out, by trail and error, how to format and reinstall windows and drivers. What a time to be alive. That computer was upgraded with a Voodoo card, a CD burner, an ISA network card (he dragged it to many LANs at friends houses and at the local youth club), at some point 32 mib ram was added too. That machine sits behind me right now, still fully functional. It's not an understatement to say that that experience formed me as a human being, as well as helped shape my future and career, having unlimited and unrestrained access to a computer as a kid probably saved my life in more ways than one. So that is one of my favorite christmas memories.

FlyingSnake 3 days ago

Merry Christmas

Feliz Natal

नाताळच्या हार्दिक शुभेच्छा!

As a kid born on X’mas eve, Christmas has been special to me, even in the dusty provincial non-Christian town of Central India.

After moving to Germany, and having a kid, I appreciate Christmas (Weihnachtsferien) even more nowadays. What a wonderful season of festivity

May this festival season bring happiness and joy to you and your loved ones.

dc_ist 3 days ago

Unwrapping Ocarina of Time. My parents had me convinced it was sold out everywhere. That moment is seared into my brain.

grumblepeet 3 days ago

The few golden years when the kids were little, we’d all sit around the TV and play console games and when a hard bit came along, like a puzzle or a jump or a big boss with loads of guns, I’d be handed the controls to do the difficult bits. I got to be the family hero. We had great fun. A few years later, they all had way faster reaction times, and their own PC’s and games, and played them in their rooms. But for a few glorious Christmas’ we all came together and it was great. I miss those times, but on the other hand I helped them build their own PC systems, and set them off on the own paths. I helped them grow.

changexd 3 days ago

Merry Christmas homies! We don't really celebrate Christmas in my country but I would still like to wish you all a great holiday! much love <3

noufalibrahim 3 days ago

I don't celebrate it but I do have a memory.

It was at my first job and first time away from home. I was single and so was a colleague from work.

There was no one in the office that night. So we installed unreal tournament, played "mistress of Christmas" out loud, ordered in some food from a nearby restaurant and played a lan game till past midnight. Then we went home.

codetrotter 3 days ago

One of my favorite memories is Christmas year 2000, when I was with my father and my grandparents on his side, and my father had bought a PlayStation 2 for me. Me and him stayed up long playing Jak and Daxter: The Precursor Legacy.

We were a bit scared to even stop playing, because we didn’t have any memory card to save progress on at first. But we left the console powered on over night and resumed playing the next day, and did the same for the next few days and then my father went and bought a memory card so we could save the progress.

Good times :)

parentheses 3 days ago

First "proper" Christmas in the US (7 years after moving here) where I got Quake III Arena. It sparked a life long love of programming that has yet to subside.

As a non Christian immigrant, my parents did their best to understand and embrace the "good parts" of Christmas. We went from just having dinner to now exchanging presents and spending time together as a family. My wife is from the US and grew up with Christmas being a very big deal (and lavish with presents). She took it to the next level once we got together. Now, with kids, it's taken on a new life.

So, I guess my real answer: Christmas just gets better every year. I hope it continues to for me and does for all of you!

Good health, wealth and tidings to all of you - kindred spirits from all around the world!

p0w3n3d 3 days ago

My best/funniest Christmas memory time was when there was a huge cold outside, so the ice froze some antenna cables together. Not sure what was the physics behind it, but the result was I got a cable television in our TV even despite we didn't pay for it. I could watch many foreign channels, except for cartoon network which was on the same channel as another channel from terrestrial, hence these were overlaying together and not possible to watch. Later when the freezing cold faded away, we bought the cable and I could better learn English from watching Cartoon Network and as a result now I can work as a software engineer

niag 3 days ago

Merry Christmas!

This year, I’m flying solo. My wife and daughter are visiting family in India, and my mum’s spending the holidays with my younger brother and his family. With the house unusually quiet, I’ve decided to knock the rust off my frontend skills and catch up with all the new tooling.

Not a bad way to spend a quiet Christmas, really. Hope everyone’s having a lovely one, whether with family or a bit of peaceful coding!

Spooky23 3 days ago

When my son was three, we setup a particularly beautiful tree and our first big light display on our front porch (the tree was just inside the big bay window)

My wife and I were dead tired, and my son woke us up in a state of complete excitement. She headed downstairs to “check for elves” and prepare a few things, with me and kiddo at the top of the stairs.

When the elves were confirmed to have vacated, I went down, followed by my son. We somehow got him to wait for me to sit on the couch and then… he rounded the corner. My son started singing “deck the halls” The look of pure joy and innocence and excitement is a memory I will treasure forever.

We’ve since tragically lost my wife to cancer, and although he’s much older now, we maintain most of the little traditions and either still believe or pretend to each other to believe a few special aspects of our celebration. Christmas was my wife’s joy and we revere it in a unique way.

  • jamiek88 3 days ago

    That was beautiful, thank you.

blindriver 3 days ago

If you are visiting SF, Christmas is the very best time to sightsee, especially in the morning. Every major location has plenty of free parking and no one is there. I have lived here for decades but Christmas is my favorite time to bring visitors because they can see everything that is normally hard to see because of parking, too many tourists etc.

kaycebasques 3 days ago

Merry Xmas everyone.

PS1 has got to be my most memorable gift. That loading screen is burned into the OLED of my subconscious.

I like how jakebasile put it though:

> Some of the finest memories are just a jumble of similar situations though.

Archetypical Xmas AM is me, my brother, and my mom. It was always a huge exercise of my willpower to wait for my brother (5 years older, lifelong night owl) to wake up. My single mom would always lavish us in gifts. We were relatively poor in our area; Xmas was the day she made us feel as wealthy as kings. I later learned that she sometimes racked up huge credit card debt to give us this experience. I haven't done an Xmas tree for myself in years but when our baby comes I will for sure revive that magical experience for her. In the late AM we would drive over to my aunt/uncle/cousins and enjoy bagels, talk about the gifts we got, and watch movies. Everyone stayed in cozy pajamas all day, I think that's a small but important part of why this day often felt different.

In later years Xmas Eve is now my fondest jumble of memories. Growing up, we did not have people at the house. I resented my mom's antisociality a bit. But then one year, the family member who usually hosted Xmas Eve said they were tired of it. Quite the surprise to everyone when my mom said she would host the next party! She's now been hosting it for 10+ years and it's always a good time every year. I'm very proud of her for coming out of her shell and being the sturdy/reliable anchor that brings the family together every year.

drmpeg 3 days ago

For me, it was Christmas Eve 1968 and the reading of Genesis from Apollo 8. My parents had just bought their first color TV.

xenocratus 3 days ago

For some reason a lot of my memories from early days are lost (despite not being that far back), but I do fondly remember us visiting some neighbours, playing Monopoly with the kids of the household (good friends at the time, that I've since long lost contact with) until late, then getting back home to find presents under the tree. I've now forgotten what the presents were, but vividly remember my mum leaving to "get something from the flat" as we were playing :)

Crăciun fericit! I can only hope for more peace in the world for the next year.

onecommentman 3 days ago

I’ll skip the well-meaning attempt at personal engagement (too old and cranky for that) and just wish everyone Merry Christmas (or whatever religious/winter solstice variants span your spiritual function space at this time of year) and the happiest of New Years.

  • heresie-dabord 3 days ago

    Happy Solstice! It's all about the axial tilt of this pale blue dot where we all need more peace, kindness, and compassion.

tsumnia 3 days ago

The year of the leopard print futon.

I thought I was the coolest kid in the world because my bed could fold up into a couch. Funny enough, I still sleep great on futons. These days if I lie down on a futon, go ahead and assume I'm about to take an hour long nap.

ChumpGPT 3 days ago

I had an awesome uncle when we were kids (70's). He was a mover and shaker, a real-life hustler, the kind of guy who carried around a stack of 100s with a rubber band around them. He wore a long fur coat with a black hat. He looked like Cramer in the episode of Seinfeld where he had the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat. Every Christmas Eve after dinner he would take me and my brother out to the movies. Good Times....Good Times....

glitchc 3 days ago

We get together as a family and make a lasagna. And before you ask, we're not Italian. It's just a fun tradition, and leads to some amazing memories.

ashitlerferad 3 days ago

As a JW I never celebrated either. It’s strange because my wife is Lutheran and she’s probably the most excited adult about Christmas I’ve ever met. Bakes the Ham, turkey, Christmas PJs, Love Actually, Home Alones and gifts Christmas morning.

I love seeing her happy as much as I love food. So it works out. I don’t get involved beyond what I would do on a regular day which is be happy for her, have good conversation and banter and eat a lot of food.

People will say well if you are not active, what’s the big deal? Well, It’s like how parents might give advice when you’re younger and some of it you outgrow or choose not to follow as you become an adult, but certain lessons stick with you for life because they feel fundamentally true. They become part of who you are. For me, not celebrating Christmas is like this. Even though I’m not actively practicing as a Jehovah’s Witness, that teaching still aligns with my values and feels like the right thing to continue avoiding it. It’s also a sign of respect and a nod to my beliefs.

  • snozolli 3 days ago

    and a nod to my beliefs.

    You could have just said that you're still a believer. Not being 'active' doesn't mean anything if you're still a believer.

    I don't know why you'd refuse to embrace the joy of Christmas in your situation. Self-denial and suffering aren't noble virtues, contrary to what religion loves to tell people. It's okay to enjoy things.

GarnetFloride 3 days ago

Merry Christmas One memory was getting a PowerMac G4 which was totally cool because it was classified as a munition.

Another was getting thru to mom while I was in Europe and watching the phone counter start counting up really fast.

wyclif 3 days ago

For me it was Christmas 1977 when me and my little brother got an Atari 2600 console. We spent almost the entire day (except for taking a break for meals) playing all the variations of Combat.

Later, in 1980, I bought Adventure with my paper route money and I had hours of fun playing that and trying to figure it out. When I finally found the Warren Robinette-created easter egg, I was ecstatic. Unfortunately, even though I was a huge fan of Adventure, it is the type of action-adventure game that when you solve the quest you quickly lose interest.

1980 was probably peak Atari 2600. By 1982, with the release of E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, the game was so terrible and rushed to market so quickly and was so obviously shovelware that I moved on from the platorm.

I miss those days though. More than anything else the Atari 2600 was what got me into learning BASIC a few years later on the TRS-80 and the IBM PC.

  • JoeAltmaier 3 days ago

    Funny you should mention ET. It was indeed shovelware, Howard's group was challenged to get a movie-tie-in game out in 12 weeks and he volunteered. Worked like a slave to get something that looked like a game, had at least one play mechanic, titles and animation! All with a tiny processor with negligible memory that had to turn the electron beam on and off in timing loops. Still proud that he got anything at all that worked. Proud of the notoriety as well, Howard is like that!

    Now he's a family counselor, a good one too. I see him a couple times a month at Movie Night, another old friend hosts those and we get good attendance even though we haven't worked together for forty years.

    Merry Christmas!

aszantu 3 days ago

Just realized, i only have one. Eating with a stranger at xmas eve in the netherlands. We were both avoiding our families because we both hate to be around fam around xmas.

rvba 3 days ago

Building the plastic christmas tree.. with my cat.

First taking out the branches from the top shelves of the closet. What was supervised by her - every branch had to be checked and smelled. After the branches were remowed she would laudly meow to be put on the shelf. For inspection.

Then she would demand to be taken down (or would jump out with a loud thud) and lie down on a branches.

Finally after some discussion the christmas tree could be build. She would supervise the whole process, look at the lamps, inspect the decorations with paws and lie observing them. Happy meows and loud purrs all the time.

Then she would lie near the christmass tree in triumph.

I miss my cat. She was very friendly and talkative

  • doormatt 2 days ago

    I'm sorry for your loss - cats can be the most loving creatures imaginable.

tmsh 3 days ago

* approx age 6-7: unwrapping a Nintendo entertainment system (part-time English teacher single-parent mom but investment banker uncle)

* a few years later: same thing with SNES

* middle school: coming back from a small ski trip and starting to read John Grisham novels.

* college: staying over one break in western mass. Biking to Hadley mall where they had an Amy’s cheese pizza and bringing it back to the German house that had an oven.

* mid 20s: watching whatever odd PBS documentary while hanging out with my mom.

* early 30s: my aunt’s lasagna and extended family meals we took for granted at the time.

* late 30s: good news after a fertility journey.

* early 40s (today): my wife and I using our decade of experience navigating edge cases when filling prescriptions to help my MIL fill an important heart medication so she didn’t have to go to the ER for Christmas.

snozolli 3 days ago

Sometime between maybe '79 and '83, there was a particularly memorable Christmas. We drove across the state to my grandparents' huge ranch home (I visited the new owners as an adult, turns out it was a normal-sized house). Waking up on Christmas morning with all my cousins, aunts, and uncles there, anxiously waiting while Grandpa built a fire in the fireplace, absolutely dying to finally open presents. Some adult walked in dressed as Santa to hand out presents and I never did figure out who it was.

herbst 3 days ago

Spending my Christmas in a caravan somewhere way south of Spain, in a quiet remote corner with only my favourite 2 people (including my dog). No presents, no family dinners. Definitely the best Christmas for a long while.

sim7c00 3 days ago

I dont like christmas atall. no good memories. i tried to escape it by marrying a muslim but now she wants to celebrate too. god i wish today was over already and i just woke up. merry christmas everyone <3

nickpsecurity 3 days ago

Merry Christmas, Hacker News!

Today is a day made for celebrating the birth of Christ. Later, a tradition of giving gifts and spending time with family. I pray God blesses you in each of these things.

If anyone here is unfamiliar with what Christmas is, this page has links explaining the birth of Christ and why it’s one of history’s greatest events:

https://www.desiringgod.org/topics/the-birth-of-christ

  • octopoc 3 days ago

    Actually gift giving at the winter solstice far predates Jesus. For instance the tradition of Santa coming down the chimney comes from a time in Britain when there was a terrible snowstorm and the poor people were starving. The Druids had food to give them but couldn’t get in the doors because the snow was so deep. So they sent the food down the chimneys!

    Having said that, merry Christmas!!

ricardo81 3 days ago

Feeding an unsuspecting and perhaps inebriated auntie dog biscuits that to be fair, looked like regular chocolate buttons.

michaelhoney 3 days ago

I’m six years old: we’re travelling and our family is in London staying in a hotel. I watch Speed Racer on television on Christmas Eve, and they jump over a gap and something clicks and I “get” momentum. That night the anticipation is almost unbearable and I pretend to sleep as my parents set out presents. In the morning we get up and the best present I get is a junior science encyclopaedia. That day the weather is terrible, so we stay inside and read and we order chicken sandwiches from room service.

jll29 2 days ago

A very happy Christmas memory was from when I was sick with measles as a kid (perhaps aged 5?), wrapped in many layers of blankets on my grandparents' sofa, watching the Christmas tree and listening to everyone's conversation and Christmas songs on TV. Despite being slightly feverish and covered with red dots all over, I was the most happy child.

The most _nerdy_ Christmas was when I returned to my mom's house as a student (probably Chris Rea playing when I rode home on the train.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDt3u2Ev1cI ), and the only kit within reach there was an old Atari ST 520+ with a copy of Berkeley Yacc (Bison) on 3.5" floppy disk next to it. I happened to have an (unrelated) machine learning paper in my backpack, so I dedided to reimplement the paper in Yacc on this ancient machine, which was most gratifying (no man pages, no Web, no StackExchange, ...).

matheusmoreira 3 days ago

My favorite memories are from family gatherings. Christmas is a magical time that can really bring the family together. We used to have them a lot when I was a kid but they just kind of stopped as I got older. As though the magic was gone.

This year I got to experience this again and it made me so happy. Seeing my family together and happy, conflicts and troubles forgotten. It was a joy I hadn't felt in such a long time, I didn't know it was still possible.

Merry Christmas, everyone.

johnxie 3 days ago

Merry Christmas and happy holidays everyone! My dad’s birthday is on Christmas, so it was always a double celebration. Growing up in Queens, we’d sometimes go to Atlantic City, taking a Greyhound or driving once we had a car. We’d head to Bally’s, enjoy the Christmas vibes, and spend hours at the buffet.

Those trips were always fun. This year, he’s in a rehab hospital on another continent after a stroke, but we’re all staying hopeful to celebrate together next year.

Yhippa 3 days ago

Merry Christmas and happy holidays to you too. One of my fondest memories was getting a tiny battery-powered train set when I was around 6. No idea why I liked it so much. We didn't have many toys growing up so you had to enjoy the heck out of the ones you did get. I remember when I opened it up the room was dark and we sat under the light of our fake Christmas tree with multicolored lights.

My kids have too much these days and wonder if they will ever experience something like that.

JoeAltmaier 3 days ago

I remember my Hindu-Jewish Christmas. I was working at a startup in the midwest. We hired lots of graduated students, including one from Israel and one from Bangalore India. They were curious about Christmas so we invited them to come to ours!

Two young kids under 10, a new house in the country and perfect weather. They arrived, and since they had heard about the gift-giving part they brought gifts! For the family, way nicer than they had to for a hostess gift but exclamations all around and thanks and we use that giant red baking pot to this day.

The Indian lad was just married and she was so curious and funny and happy to be with family - they had found America to be so quiet and empty! To be in a full house again with kids and noise and decorations and ceremony - she was ecstatic.

We introduced all the foods (my wife was a champ and had come up with things everybody could eat! A Christmas miracle in itself) and the trappings (lights and trees and drinks and songs) and had a lovely loud silly evening.

Later, each of those co-worker mentioned independently that though they'd lived in America for years, that was the very first time they'd been invited into an American's home. They were so grateful. Even today, thirty years later, I can call either of those guys and be greeted like an old Uncle.

So yeah, I remember that one from time to time and smile.

mikewarot 3 days ago

I always enjoyed the family get togethers over at my Father in law's house. There was always a festive spirit and plenty of really tasty food.

  • sowbug 3 days ago

    I didn't like my stepfather, but his family did Christmas right. We'd all go to his parents' house, and it seemed like there were a hundred family members there. Incredible food, tamales, a big pot of beans and fresh corn tortillas, carnitas. The grandfather did the Santa Claus tradition, handing out the presents in full costume and character, after which my 50 step-cousins and I would absolutely destroy whatever toys we had just received.

    When bedtime arrived, of course there weren't enough beds for everyone, so each of us kids would grab couch cushions, find a nook somewhere between two pieces of furniture, and sleep like the dead on the 1970s plush carpet.

    My mom wised up a few years later and divorced him, instantly improving the other 364 days of the year. But I missed those crazy Christmases.

zoklet-enjoyer 3 days ago

Christmas is also my birthday. On my 30th birthday I ignored all of my friends and family and played Crash Bandicoot on PS4 all day. It was great.

  • samatman 3 days ago

    I have a cousin who shares your birthday. Her name is Merry Noel.

    Hope you're having a merry Noel as well. ^_^

    • zoklet-enjoyer 2 days ago

      Thank you and merry Christmas!

      That's a great name. Do you know if Christmas was her mom's expected due date? Kind of wondering if they had the name planned before she was born or if they came up with it because she happened to come on xmas

      • samatman a day ago

        The latter I've been told, she came out a couple weeks ahead of schedule.

silisili 3 days ago

My favorite memory as a kid was waking up in the middle of the night and seeing a large object covered in the living room, and thinking it was elves and I had to tip toe back to bed because my parents said they'd run off if they saw me. It was a Go-Kart, wrapped in a bed sheet. Great gift.

My favorite memory as an adult was filling the kid's stocking with nothing but bananas one year. She was 6. At first she was pretend excited because she likes bananas, but by the end she was digging, pulling them out one by one and saying 'aw man another banana' each time. She then asked us why Santa brought her so many bananas, and I had to pretend not to know through my tears of laughter.

She gets great gifts, just having a bit of fun. We put a banana on top of her stocking each year since, but she's old enough now to roll her eyes and sigh.

corytheboyd 3 days ago

A simple one!

One year it was just my parents and I for Christmas. None of us are that big on elaborate gift giving, we just want to see each other. Unknowingly we had all purchased some form of booze for one another, so we spent the evening chatting with libations by the fire, it was wonderful :)

frereubu 3 days ago

Christmas in 1982/3 in the UK, I was praying desperately for a ZX Spectrum so I could play Manic Miner like my nephews (who, due to a generational slip were more like my cousins) and was genuinely crushed when I opened my present to find that it was a BBC Micro Model B. The horror! Although Elite did make up for quite a bit of that, the game scene on the BBC was so much worse (or at least it felt so) and I ended up copying code by hand for games from magazines, which I'm pretty sure was what my parents intended. Fast forward to now, and I'm running a successful web agency, having worked my way through various internet-related jobs in interesting organisations like the BBC, universities and others. So a belated and slightly begrudging thanks to my dad and mum for their foresight.

gsch1 2 days ago

Growing up in South Brazil, my childhood was filled with tropical vibes. I remember the sweltering heat, with temperatures often between 29-35°C. Santa Claus, dressed in winter clothes, would be sweating and nearly fainting. Our holiday meals were a unique mix of turkey and barbecue, and the adults always had plenty of beer. It was always a big family reunion, with 15-30 people gathering together. Crazy to think about it.

nikolay a day ago

   ______  __           __         __     __          ______                           _______  __               __   ___          _______  __           
  |      ||  |--..----.|__|.-----.|  |_  |__|.-----. |   __ \.-----..----..-----.     |     __||  |.-----..----.|__|.'  _|.--.--. |   |   ||__|.--------.
  |   ---||     ||   _||  ||__ --||   _| |  ||__ --| |   __ <|  _  ||   _||     | __  |    |  ||  ||  _  ||   _||  ||   _||  |  | |       ||  ||        |
  |______||__|__||__|  |__||_____||____| |__||_____| |______/|_____||__|  |__|__||  | |_______||__||_____||__|  |__||__|  |___  | |___|___||__||__|__|__|
                                                                                  |_|                                     |_____|
dgan 3 days ago

When i arrived in France, i couldn't help but notice that people celebrate New Year ar 25 December instead of 1st January. eventually, after learning the language, I understood that it is actually another thing altogether!

gosub100 3 days ago

Christmas '98, my mom went to the local computer tech and bought me the 166mhz MMX CPU. I was stoked (but admittedly a little bit frustrated it wasn't the 233mhz). As silly as this seems, the black lacquered laminate (instead of the gray ceramic on my 133mhz or 100mhz or whatever I had) made me feel like I went from a nova to a corvette. I fondly remember getting excited about that kind of stuff. Also that same year, my first intro to 3D, playing motocross madness with my highschool friend on my (or probably his) new voodoo 3DFX card. It was magical.

  • Tepix 3 days ago

    Indeed, seeing the 3dfx in action for the first time was super magical.

freeone3000 3 days ago

The last christmas I was able to spend with my dad's side of the family. My nieces and nephews gathered around the tree - absolutely spoiled rotten by their parents and their second cousin who had a tech salary and no responsibilities. Their faces when they were able to open the gifts of the sort I wish I could have had -- a robotics kit, a goo-making set, a diamond painting, a nintendo switch game. Being able to give them cool things that I hope they continued to enjoy for months to come. The feeling of sitting around a bonfire made of present-trash, beer in hand, talking about nothing. It's how I feel Christmas should be.

jonpurdy 3 days ago

Growing up celebrating Xmas in Canada resulted in me dreading the month before with Xmas music and decorations everywhere. As an adult I love that I can mostly choose not to celebrate (aside from parents and inlaws). Even living in Korea I avoided the celebrations but couldn’t avoid the decorations.

But I do really enjoy one single thing about the holidays: the VLC icon getting a Santa hat a couple of weeks before Dec 25.

VLC has been doing this as long as I can remember (earlier than 2005?) and it’s literally the one thing I look forward to for the holidays.

ethagnawl 3 days ago

Merry Christmas and happy holidays to all.

I haven't used Ruby in about five years but I'm still looking forward to reading the release notes for 3.4(?) over coffee in the morning, as I've done every Christmas for about 15 years.

shannifin 3 days ago

Christmas 1996, I was 11. We finally got a modern computer with Windows 95, a CD-ROM drive, speakers, Oregon Trail 2... It was magical! The only time I ever wept with joy over a Christmas present.

devilbunny 3 days ago

Merry Christmas indeed. Even if you’re not Christian. The holiday has become larger than the religion, and I think that is something Jesus would have liked. His point was always love.

v8xi 2 days ago

Christmas 1999 my father's business had just gone under when the banks stopped lending after the dot com bubble. We didn't have any presents until Christmas morning when our church dropped off a bunch of presents for us. We got a Razor scooter and I spent all day riding it downstairs. I just got my daughter a scooter and she's doing the same this year :)

joemazerino 3 days ago

Having the extended family over and the boys would all be playing outside until the street lights came on, and then inside to play whatever game came out. Clay fighter, mortal kombat, donkey kong country etc.

My family would pull straws to see which man would dress up as Santa clause and go door to door on my street to greet kids and give the adults some baileys or whiskey.

Great times. Merry Christmas.

darepublic 3 days ago

Waking up at 5 in the morning and playing shareware computer games on our IBM 286 with my sister. My dad discovering this and joining us.

jamexcb 2 days ago

I received an empty, small blue plastic toolbox. For me, it was the most amazing thing because now I had my own toolbox, like my father and i could add anything to it. I still have that box. I love it.

remarkEon 3 days ago

Merry Christmas!

I don't actually have this memory, since I was 2 and a half years old.

My parents wanted to go back to South Dakota and have a proper "family" Christmas, with all of the cousins and all of the babies. Well, Christmas was had and then the temp dropped to -30°F. My parents scrambled to get me into the car and drove overnight from South Dakota back to Minneapolis to try and escape the storm.

ashton314 3 days ago

I’ve always loved Christmas—I’m blessed that it’s all good memories. But having a little kid the past few years is a whole new level of magic.

Merry Christmas everyone. :)

benreesman 3 days ago

Merry Christmas HN!

I’ve spent a lot of holidays alone over the last few years, and the HN community was a joy and a comfort every time.

I have the pleasure of spending holidays with family this year, and I’m trying to answer everyone’s questions about computer stuff, I invariably wind up referring to the great comments on HN as the best resource around.

I look forward to spending another year with all of you, and hope you all have a wonderful holiday.

soulofmischief 3 days ago

I don't have many good Christmas memories, so I would probably say my favorite is when I received Pokémon Gold and a Gameboy Color at age 5. That game opened up a lot for me and had a huge influence on my life, philosophy and career.

Merry Christmas, everyone. Hug 'em if you got 'em.

unethical_ban 3 days ago

N64, Sega Genesis, Huffy bikes. Snow once, in the early 2000s in Houston.

It's a Wonderful Life each year.

More, but I'm tired, and it's Christmas! Merry Christmas all.

I remember real for trees as a kidm I haven't had one for five or more years now.

Not having the internet on Christmas. All is quiet.

Turn off news and social media on Christmas! Just respond to well wishes, that's fine.

loumf 2 days ago

I took digital electronics when I was in high school. Some classmates wrote a version of “The 12 Days of Christmas” except with names of chips instead of the usual gifts.

The only line I can remember is “Five 555s”

jamieplex 3 days ago

Merry Christmas! Just remembering playing with our new Commodore 64, Christmas Day 1982. Good memories.

qntmfred 3 days ago

And on earth peace, goodwill toward men

sneak 3 days ago

1991. I received a Super Nintendo on Christmas morning at age 7. Within minutes I was playing the single bundled game on a large Trinitron CRT in the living room.

It’s more than 30 years later and I still regard SMW as the best video game ever made.

hooverd 3 days ago

Listening to David Sedaris' Six to Eight Black Men. It's an amazing bit.

jjtheblunt 3 days ago

I’m secular and Xmas for us meant unbounded time in the snow after possibly fun toys when little, as the Santa thing we knew as Santa far more than anything religious.

DoctorOetker 3 days ago

Is there going to be a 2024 Donald Knuth Christmas Lecture?

weishigoname 2 days ago

Merry Christmas! every Christmas is memorable when family gather together and share what changed during this year.

thomasfromcdnjs 2 days ago

My friend brought over a blow up pool and beers. Took us 6 hours before we realized we both had our shorts on backwards.

unboxedvariable 3 days ago

Merry Christmas HN!

Hope everyone was able to slow down the pace a little, connect a little more with people we may have not caught up with recently and send/receive positive vibes. And happy new year.

Yawrehto 2 days ago

Have a merry Christmas, wonderful Hannukah, and, if you're atheist, a wonderful…birthday of Isaac Newton?

borski 3 days ago

Happy Hanukkah as well! It starts tonight. :)

uncomplexity_ 3 days ago

lots of alcohol, cigarettes, and karaoke's

time is fleeting gents

RobRivera 3 days ago

Ho ho ho Its christmas time (5 tabs open)

pmarreck 3 days ago

The Christmas our family got our first computer, a Mac 128k, stands out.

Also, the Christmas I got the Atari 2600.

reynaldi 3 days ago

Merry Christmas, Hacker News! Hope you’re staying cozy and enjoying time with loved ones.

SchwKatze 3 days ago

Merry Christmas! I love this community, hope you all enjoy this time

monkeydust 3 days ago

Getting a Nintendo NES with Super Mario 3, was probably 10 :-p

ninjamayo 2 days ago

Merry Christmas to everyone! I've read a few great stories in here and thought of sharing mine. My childhood Christmas were never that special unfortunately and during my teen years, life was pretty tough. But I do have great memories from all the Christmas I had my wife over the past 20 years. We established a lot of Christmas traditions for our families, since I never had any from my childhood to share. Actually we just finished watching the Raiders of the Lost Ark and spent two hours talking about great cinema and of course me playing the Indiana Jones game from Lucasarts. Oh wish, I could get back in time and play that game for the first time. Not quite the same playing it these days, the magic unfortunately is gone.

So yeah today was a great Christmas day! All the best to the HN community.

29athrowaway 3 days ago

Creating the illusion that Santa exists and left gifts behind.

ngcc_hk 2 days ago

Wish all well. Silence night after then gift opening (sorry the argument to wait for boxing days lost)

TL;dr.

No need like the communist china to object to Xmas so much that is it since 2023 (?) say silence night should be used to remember those soliders they sent to fight in North Korea against USA army, mostly died due to freezing cold and anyway many are not pla but nationalist surrender soldiers.

Let us have a little kindness, even if atheists or communists. Fir one second.

maz1b 3 days ago

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to all celebrating!

omnee 3 days ago

So many beautiful stories. Merry Christmas Everyone!

4dregress 3 days ago

Merry Xmas, I hope you all have a great day!

radar1310 3 days ago

Merry Christmas to all and to all a nice tech gift.

maxcruer 3 days ago

Too bad I had to be in the hospital :(

michaelsbradley 3 days ago

Merry Christmas

Christus natus est

O Χριστός γεννιέται

Христос раждается

המשיח נולד

ابن الله يولد اليوم

recursivedoubts 3 days ago

My first Christmas vigil mass.

Merry Christmas everyone.

kurisufag 3 days ago

just listening to the radio.

htk 3 days ago

Merry Christmas, hackers!

prydt 2 days ago

Merry Christmas!

ddingus 3 days ago

Merry Christmas!

Thank all of you for being here and for the most part, being real.

We are a fundamentally good crowd.

Be nice to one another please. It counts in this world. A world where guilty pleasures like this one we share are seemingly on the way out, back filled with soulless places nobody really cares about.

gedy 3 days ago

Christmas 1992 was in basic military training and for most people was a nice dinner and a break from the yelling. Our flight 083 was the unlucky ones picked for kitchen and cleaning duty... Cleaning old food out of a floor drain by hand on Christmas night was gross and humbling but has made the Christmases since all the more pleasant.

russellbeattie 3 days ago

"Why is the top bar of HN red? Oh yeah... It's Christmas."

- Me, pretty much every year.

Got my TRS-80 Color Computer 2 in 1981. Much of my entire life was shaped by that computer.

submeta 3 days ago

Yesterday at the Christmas Vespers in Germany. A full church. The Christmas story is being told—about Jesus, about the Romans, about the darkness in the stable, and how the Christ child is born in Bethlehem. But no word about an ongoing Genocide in Palestine (the Pope says it‘s a genocide, all human rights orgs say it’s genocide). About Israel bombing Palestinians into pieces. Sick world.

  • Abdumaa 3 days ago

    Yeah, it feels deeply troubling to see this contrast. I wonder who the romans are today... The oppression affects all palestinians (not just muslims but also christians). Anyone staying silent about this suffering should feel ashamed.

codevark 3 days ago

When I was six my parents got me a 26" Schwinn single-speed bike. It was as tall as I was. I rode it until college, doing things that were heretofore unknown to science. IT WAS GREAT.

7e 3 days ago

[flagged]

  • compootr 3 days ago

    I think it's less of a religious holiday and more of an american (and some other countries) tradition that supercedes religion -- while not in name.

    hope you're doing well right now. merry christmas (omg religion1!%1) and happy holidays. maybe touch some grass before getting angry about a holiday where a fake fat guy brings people gifts ;)

consf 3 days ago

[flagged]

katamari-damacy 3 days ago

Merry Xmas!

I have to ask though, given America is a multicultural country: how come we don’t see celebrations on HN of the other two Abrahamic religions? I mean they have their own religious holidays and celebrations, and one actually coincides with Xmas this year.

Why the waspy vibe on HN?

  • olalonde 3 days ago

    Christmas is much more widely celebrated. Pretty much everyone in my family is atheist and we've always celebrated it. I'm in China right now and many of my Chinese friends are doing something for Christmas and wishing me "Merry Christmas", despite none of them being Christian. There are Christmas trees and decorations everywhere. It has become more of a cultural celebration than a religious one for many people around the world.

  • michaelsshaw 3 days ago

    Christmas is not about Jesus at all, it's the American red-and-green snowy holiday with family, Santa, gifts and drinking. It's not perceived as a religious holiday by most of us. If you want those other threads, then perhaps you should personally create them. I'm sure nobody here will be upset with that.

    As an aside, the letter X a literal form of Jesus's name.

    • tyrd12io 2 days ago

      It's not perceived as a religious holiday by most of us - of course not when majority of them are christians. For rest of us its a religious holiday. by not acknowledging it as religious event, you are just ignoring people of other faiths.

  • jondwillis 3 days ago

    There’s still a lot more Christian than Muslim or Jewish people in the USA/YC-prone countries, as well as people that celebrate it in some way for cultural reasons. So, demographics and it isn’t actually about religion at all for a lot of people.

    • tempestn 3 days ago

      Yep, exactly. Very few of my friends are religious at all, but we all celebrate Christmas. Not as a religious holiday, but as a time that by tradition we spend time and share gifts and love with friends and family.

      • vlunkr 3 days ago

        This is the beautiful thing about Christmas. It’s a buildup of hundreds of years of traditions if you trace it back to Saturnalia. It’s a mix of ancient and modern customs, folklore from many cultures, and infinite family or personal traditions. The Christian angle is certainly there, but you can leave it out entirely and still have a full experience.

  • let_me_post_0 3 days ago

    Christianity is uniquely welcoming in a way that neither Islam nor Judaism are. Judaism is exclusive and you're not invited. Islam is more similiar to Christianity but in many ways mutually exclusive with it, so again not really inviting for us in the western hemisphere with a Christian background.

    In any case it is not up to people with a Christian background to decide to get their noses in the traditions of other cultures. That would be culturally insensitive. You should have posed this question to the Muslims and the Jews of America.

    • dcuthbertson 3 days ago

      > Judaism is exclusive and you're not invited.

      That's not strictly true. I suspect those that follow Orthodox and Ultra Orthodox Judaism are exclusive. However, those that follow Reform Judaism and the Conservative Movement support conversion to Judaism, so you are invited.

    • jyounker 3 days ago

      > Christianity is uniquely welcoming in a way that neither Islam nor Judaism are.

      That's not been my experience at all.

    • nraf 3 days ago

      Following your logic, Christianity would be not be inviting to those in Muslim-majority countries.

  • burgerzzz 3 days ago

    Do you post similar comments on other religious holidays?

  • disambiguation 3 days ago

    Anyone can make a thread, maybe ask them why they choose not to?